How to accelerate customer acquisition at banks and financial firms
Connecting with customers, deepening relationships, and fostering loyalty are key growth drivers for financial organizations, especially during tough economic times. Gaining consumer trust accelerates client acquisition, retention, and advocacy. Yet many teams struggle to understand what drives consumer trust. What’s often missing is a dedicated strategy for measuring and improving it.
According to Forrester’s Consumer Banking Trends Report, trust isn’t abstract. Using data to prioritize, design, execute, and measure various efforts, you can build and strengthen trust.
However, in banking, current methods for collecting customer experience data are insufficient to understand what it’s really like to be your customer. Only half of all newly opened bank accounts survive 90 days, and only a smaller subset is active and profitable. The question is—why?
The hard truth is that metrics like net promotor score (NPS) and web analytics aren’t actionable. Yes, they can alert a team to a problem, but they don’t enable the team to confidently make decisions that lead to meaningful improvements in customer experience.
This guide explains why survey results and NPS aren’t enough for banks and large financial organizations to understand their customers. It also demonstrates how to quickly dig deeper with qualitative data to improve customer experience and drive acquisition and retention.
What's inside
Why NPS and survey results aren't enough
While banks and financial organizations pride themselves on being data-driven, they often only use one type of data. Quantitative data and analytics tools have been relied on to inform corporate strategies for many years. Some would even consider them foundational for decision-making. At all levels of a business, especially in the boardroom, it’s easy to understand quantitative performance metrics and tie them to ROI.
NPS and survey data tell you what's happening, not why
All too often, qualitative data isn’t given the same level of importance. Qualitative data includes customer insights, feedback, and observations from interviews and usability tests, to name a few. The value of this kind of data is perceived as more difficult to quantify and attribute to ROI, which is the reason why it remains underutilized today. In the past, qualitative data was also incredibly time-consuming and expensive, making it rare to come by. However, the value that qualitative data brings is immense. Qualitative data allows for a deeper analysis of customers' thoughts and perspectives through probing questions that enhance an organization’s knowledge, understanding, and empathy for its customers. You can understand how customers think. You can find out things like why they decided to purchase or not purchase a product and whether or not they find your product valuable.
The major limitation of only using quantitative data, like survey results and NPS, is that while it can tell you something is happening, it can’t tell you why it’s happening or what’s the solution.
Quantitative data focuses on the past
Additionally, these are historical data points. Quantitative metrics can indeed shed light on customer satisfaction, but they aren’t forward-looking. By the time they hit your desk, the poor customer experience has already occurred. Any effort on your part to triage the situation is reactionary, which makes quantitative data difficult to leverage when trying to drive innovation.
As markets continue to change rapidly, making decisions based on purely historical data without additional insight into what people expect is risky. Predicting the future based on what has happened in the past won’t work anymore. It’s insufficient to make decisions and differentiate your organization from the competition.
Grant YuradaSr. Manager, UX Product Design at ExperianUserTesting empowers us to have a much more strategic approach than NPS alone because it delivers far richer human insight.
The power of quantitative and qualitative data together
While the topic of qualitative vs. quantitative data may sound intimidating, it’s easy to understand. While quantitative data is the method that most people are familiar with and the one that gets all the credit, the two data sets complement each other.
Together, they can give banks and financial organizations a more holistic view of a problem or situation. Having one without the other means you’re only getting half the story. That’s why both play a valuable role in measuring your customer experience.
For example, Amazon Seller Central leverages both quantitative and qualitative data to keep its finger on the pulse of customers and sellers. While quantitative data, like customer satisfaction, is a key success metric for Amazon, the team uses qualitative data to dig deeper into the problem and potential solutions.
Listen to the Amazon Seller Central team explain their method for staying customer-obsessed via data.
Thanks to using quantitative and qualitative data, Amazon Seller Central can address a wide range of issues and stay profitable.
Master digital customer empathy to stay competitive
Customers are not fixed data points. So we can’t use static data points to understand and connect with them. Using data is, however, still critical.
According to McKinsey, the fight for customer relationships has moved to a new terrain unfamiliar to banks. Many incumbents are ill-equipped to defend market share on the digital battlefield as niche players siphon off smaller customer segments. The secret to survival is that banks need to rearticulate their value using the power of customer experience and learn how to create value through data.
Banks and large financial organizations should aspire to offer a customer experience similar to tech companies. After all, consumers compare experiences to the best ones they've ever had. Companies like Amazon, Netflix, and Disney constantly raise the bar for great digital and in-person experiences, and the bar eventually becomes the baseline for what consumers expect.
This means using quantitative and qualitative data for hyper-personalization and stronger customer engagement, implementing agile operating models to respond rapidly to changing markets and customer preferences, and speeding up innovation.
Harsha ThayiSr. Manager, User Experience, T. Rowe PriceThat’s the value of UserTesting Human Insight Platform. It helps us close experience gaps at today’s speed of business, which is especially helpful in today’s work-from-home environment.
Start connecting with customers
Now that we’ve covered why you should use qualitative data alongside the quantitative data that you’ve traditionally relied on, let's talk about how to do this. While getting qualitative data was expensive and time-consuming in the past, connecting directly with customers can be done quickly and easily with the use of an insight platform.
Insight platforms allow you to engage with real people as they use your product, mobile app, services, and more. With access to an insight platform, teams throughout your organization gain a vivid, first-person understanding of what it’s like to be your customer. They can share customer insight videos across the organization. This makes it easier to achieve cross-functional alignment around your customers' needs.
With fast access to real people speaking their unique perspectives, banks and financial institutions can:
- Ground business decisions in the voice of the customer to reduce customer acquisition costs
- Align front-end and back-end teams around customer needs to speed up onboarding
- Test throughout the customer journey to turn active customers into loyal advocates
Through the UserTesting Human Insight Platform, anyone in an organization can easily get a vivid, first-person understanding of any experience and build greater customer empathy.
Operationalize customer empathy cross-functionally
If using qualitative data is new to your team, getting a high ROI on your customer insight investment may take a little practice, but stick to these key steps, and you'll quickly start to see results:
- Get leadership fully on board to facilitate the adoption
- Give cross-functional teams direct access to customers via an insight platform
- Have managers develop a plan for how they want to incorporate customer empathy into their current processes
- Share customer feedback throughout the organization
- Promote a customer-centric culture
It’s doubtful that one team owns every step of the customer journey at your organization. Yet, connecting with customers frequently and consistently throughout their journey is key to optimizing your experience to foster trust.
So, let’s walk through common steps in the customer journey for banks and large financial organizations. This will help you understand how the qualitative data that an insight platform provides can be leveraged at every stage of the customer journey.
Customer acquisition
Acquiring customers is costly. The banking industry's average customer acquisition cost (CAC) is above $300, and it’s risen since COVID-19. That’s why financial organizations need to do more pre and post-click to optimize their efforts.
With an insight platform, customer acquisition decisions move from opinion-based to customer-informed. Digital marketing teams can test their messaging with customers before they launch. Digital product and experience teams can see if what they’re planning to offer is actually valuable to customers before they invest budget and resources into developing it.
Teams can discover opportunities to grow by working with unbanked and underbanked segments and targeting them with tailored offers based on their unique needs.
A great option for digital teams is to start by using templates. UserTesting templates are layouts designed by qualitative research experts, complete with pre-written tasks and questions, so that non-research teams can quickly get the answers they need. Templates can be used as-is to guide you—or customized to fit your needs. We offer one for almost any kind of focus, whether you're prioritizing persona-based discovery, website evaluation, or mobile app evaluation, to name a few.
Templates to get started
- Persona characteristics - Bring your customer personas to life with insight into their attitude and behavior
- Value proposition validation - Test your value proposition with insights from your target customer
How Everypaw by Cardif Pinnacle uses human insight to refine TV campaigns
Front-end customer onboarding
A great onboarding experience reinforces trust in your organization. According to Jim Marous, onboarding should feel like a single process, no matter how many channels are used. Customers expect premium digital experiences to
- Be consistent across multiple channels
- Avoid repeatedly asking for the same information
- Function in near real-time with accuracy
- Keep them informed and provide process transparency
Knowing that your onboarding process could be improved differs from watching customers struggle with a task. It’s hard to forget a painful experience when you see it yourself.
Fixing painful experiences before they reach your customers and potential customers has a direct impact on growth. Think about all the business being left on the table with 60% of prospective banking customers dropping off during onboarding, and 43% of those with a low onboarding satisfaction score either “definitely or probably” switching banks as a result. Qualitative data helps you find out why. This is what makes empathy actionable.
Watching videos of customers going through your onboarding process gives you instant visibility into where the friction lies. Easily pinpoint processes and tasks that need streamlining. Whether a mom of three is struggling to set up a new account or a grandparent wants to transfer funds to their grandchild, your teams can quickly identify these frustrations and escalate the priority by sharing insight videos with leadership. Since people aren’t numbers, they turn static data points into real stories that are easy to remember and communicate to others.
To give you an idea of what video-based customer feedback looks like, we ran a quick test to ask bank customers what their banks could do differently to improve their life greatly. Here's what they said:
Templates to get started
- Customer journey - Understand how customers engage with your offerings across multiple touchpoints
- Messaging comprehension - Find out if audiences understand what you’re saying
How Wise improves its mobile app and website based on customer feedback
Catherine RichardsHead of Customer Design at Tesco BankUserTesting is a real staple for us in the design practice at Tesco Bank. It allows us to connect with customers and understand customers in much more depth.
Back-end customer onboarding
What happens in the back end when customers are onboarded is just as critical as what the customer sees. Determine optimal internal workflows to mitigate customer drop-off during back-end application processing. Know where and how to re-engineer processes based on feedback from cross-functional teams and make improvements to fit them.
With customer feedback, push ideas and determine winning approaches faster, allowing more experimentation in production speeds innovation. Test manual exception-handling processes to develop agile rules of engagement or uncover opportunities to automate workflows.
Templates to get started
- Mobile app evaluation - Asses critical app characteristics such as appearance, ease of use, and trust
- System usability scale evaluation - Measure a product’s ease of use with the System Usability Scale
How T. Rowe Price quickly solves critical problems
Customer activation
Motivating someone to open a checking account requires a massive coordinated effort. When you succeed, it’s tempting to call it a win. In reality, you’ve earned the opportunity to make or lose money. Don’t leave revenue on the table by failing to activate new customers.
When a checking account holder considers your institution their primary provider, they’re four times more likely to sign up for additional services. Trust in your organization could deliver an average of $212 in incremental profits annually.
To activate customers, connect with them consistently to validate that you’re providing meaningful customer support as they become regular product or service users. Discover what makes active customers more loyal and what makes them become advocates.
Templates to get started
- Feature prioritization - See how customers prioritize what matters most
- Needs and frustrations discovery - Identify opportunities to improve your customer experience
- Data privacy templates - Optimize data privacy for transparency, accessibility, and trust
Customer engagement
Improve your customer engagement strategy by prioritizing the human touch. Strengthen customer empathy amongst staff, ensure that you’re providing a consistent experience across all channels, and optimize digital and in-branch engagement.
Deepen your customer relationships through data-driven personalization. Use qualitative insight to discover what personalization is valuable to customers and validate that your personalization efforts are paying off.
Templates to get started
- Diverse and inclusive perspectives - Learn how experiences differ across groups to serve all customers better.
- Customer environment and context - Gain a deeper understanding of a customer’s environment and how your product fits in.
- Product adoption - Understand what keeps your most loyal customers engaged.
- Sustainability perception testing - Understand customer expectations and sentiment around sustainable finance
- Inflation and customer perception - Gain insight into what customers are thinking, expecting, and doing during uncertain markets
Get actionable customer data
To balance out the challenges of being a large organization in a heavily regulated industry, focus on what matters—your customers. While quantitative data is great for tying your team’s efforts to ROI, it’s not great at creating customer empathy, nor can it offer solutions for a chart that’s trending downward.
As customer needs and expectations continue to change rapidly, banks and large financial organizations need data and technology that moves with them. Ensure that your customers are more than numbers in a spreadsheet and that your customer experience feels more than a transaction.
Additional resources
Free trial
Human Insight Platform trial
See, hear, and talk to your customers first-hand to understand how they experience your brand, products, services, and in-person experiences.Industry report
The UK Banking Empathy Experience Index (EXi)
When loyalty is impacted, financial organizations must rebuild trust amongst their customers. Learn how to do this through empathy-driven experiences.Report